How Do Colleges Evaluate Extracurricular Activities? Colleges use a holistic admissions process, evaluating applicants based on various factors, including academic performance, personal essays, letters of recommendation, standardized test scores (if applicable), and extracurricular activities. Extracurricular activities are essential to this process, as they provide insight into an applicant’s character, interests, and potential to contribute to the campus community. Here’s how colleges evaluate extracurricular activities: 1. Depth of Involvement Colleges value depth over breadth when it comes to extracurriculars. A student who has dedicated significant time and energy to a few activities, rather than participating in many activities superficially, is often more appealing. This shows commitment, passion, and the ability to balance multiple responsibilities. For example, a student who has been a leader in a club for several years or has held a key position in a community service ...